Dave Portnoy's Top Pizza Places in Toronto
Updated: 2 days ago
The short answer
Dave Portnoy's best pizza in Toronto is North of Brooklyn Pizzeria on Queen Street West, which scored 8.4. No Toronto pizzeria got above 9, against 9.4 for his best US spots. This list covers the 10 highest-rated places from his Toronto trip, including Mississauga and Etobicoke.
Dave Portnoy (El Presidente) is famous for his One Bite Pizza Reviews. He has visited and reviewed more than 2000+ pizza places in the US alone. Recently he visited Canada and reviewed pizzas around the Toronto region.
Last updated: November 2026
Update (November 2026): Penn Entertainment bought the rest of Barstool Sports in February 2023, then sold it back to Dave Portnoy for $1 in August 2023. Portnoy owns Barstool again today.
Want the top scores in one list? See our Dave Portnoy pizza rankings, highest score first.
Dave Portnoy came to Canada for the Red Sox Blue Jays games hosted by theScore which was recently purchased by Penn National Gaming, the company that currently owns part of Barstool Sports and plans to own it entirely by 2023. In this list, you will notice that Dave only reviewed pizza places in Toronto, We will continue to update the list as he travels more of Canada. Here is a list of Top 10 Pizza Spots in Canada:
1. North of Brooklyn Pizzeria (Toronto, ON)
Rating - 8.4/10 | Yelp Rating - 4.4/5
Location - 650 1/2 Queen Street W Toronto, ON; Restaurant Website - Order Here
2. Pizzeria Badiali (Toronto, ON)
Rating - 8.3/10 | Yelp Rating - 4.5/5
Location - 181 Dovercourt Rd, Toronto, ON; Restaurant Website - Order Here
3. Conzo's Pizza (Toronto, ON)
Rating - 8.2/10 | Yelp Rating - 4.5/5
Location - 1279 Bloor St W, Toronto, ON; Restaurant Website - Order Here
4. Descendant Detroit Style Pizza (Toronto, ON)
Rating - 8.1/10 | Yelp Rating - 4.5/5
Descendant Detroit Style Pizza
Location - 1168 Queen Street E Toronto, ON; Restaurant Website - Order Here
5. Pizza Nostra (Mississauga, ON)
Rating - 8/10 | Yelp Rating - 4.5/5
Location - 1168 Queen Street E Toronto, ON; Restaurant Website - Order Here
6. One Night Only Pizza (Toronto, ON)
Rating - 7.9/10 | Yelp Rating - 4.8/5
One Night Only Pizza (Toronto,
Location - 581 Pape Ave, Toronto, ON; Restaurant Website - Order Here
7. SanRemo Bakery (Etobicoke, ON)
Rating - 7.8/10 | Yelp Rating - 4.5/5
SanRemo Bakery (Etobicoke, ON)
Location - 374 Royal York Road Etobicoke, ON; Restaurant Website - Order Here
8. Superpoint (Toronto, ON)
Rating - 7.7/10 | Yelp Rating - 4.5/5
Superpoint (Toronto, ON)
Location - 184 Ossington Ave, Toronto, ON; Restaurant Website - Order Here
9. Bitondo's Pizzeria (Toronto, ON)
Rating - 7.5/10 | Yelp Rating - 4/5
Bitondo's Pizzeria (Toronto, O
Location - 11 Clinton St, Toronto, ON; Restaurant Website - Not Available
10. The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria (Toronto, ON)
Rating - 7.5/10 | Yelp Rating - 4/5
Fourth Man in the Fire Pizza
Location -832 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON; Restaurant Website - Order Here
Also, Support Local Businesses; Donate to Barstool Fund
Source: BlogTO, One Bite, Yelp, and Toronto Life
Here is a list of the top 5 pizza places in Toronto, Canada recommended by Dave Portnoy (El Presidente)
S. No. | Pizza Place | Dave Score | Yelp Score |
1 | North of Brooklyn Pizzeria | 8.4/10 | 4.4/5 |
2 | Pizzeria Badiali | 8.3/10 | 4.5/5 |
3 | Conzo's Pizza | 8.2/10 | 4.5/5 |
4 | Descendant Detroit Style Pizza | 8.1/10 | 4.5/5 |
5 | Pizza Nostra | 8/10 | 4.5/5 |
Frequently asked questions
What is Dave Portnoy's best pizza in Toronto?
North of Brooklyn Pizzeria on Queen Street West, with a score of 8.4.
How many Toronto pizzerias did Dave Portnoy review?
This list covers the 10 highest-rated spots from his Toronto trip, including Mississauga and Etobicoke.
Did any Toronto pizzeria score above 9?
No. The top score in Toronto was 8.4, lower than his best US spots, which reach 9.4.
Comments